A fill-up makes driving costs visible. A car’s falling resale value does not. Yet both belong in the price of every mile. Add insurance, maintenance, financing and taxes, and roughly $1 per mile becomes a useful starting budget for a new car, before parking and tolls. The crucial qualification: this is a first-five-years benchmark, not a measured lifetime average. [1] [3]
AAA’s 2026 Your Driving Costs analysis estimates annual ownership and operating expenses of $12,863 at 15,000 miles a year, or about 86 cents per mile. At 10,000 miles, the estimate is $10,992, or $1.10 per mile. At 20,000 miles, annual spending reaches $14,799, while the per-mile figure falls to 74 cents. [1]
The biggest expense is not fuel
At AAA’s 15,000-mile benchmark, depreciation—the purchase price minus estimated resale value—is the largest expense: $4,422 annually, or nearly 30 cents per mile. Fuel or electricity contributes about 17 cents, full-coverage insurance 14 cents, and maintenance, repairs and tires nearly 12 cents. Financing adds about 8 cents; license, registration and taxes add roughly 5 cents. [1]
These are modeled expenses averaged over five years, including estimated future costs—not simply bills arriving after purchase. Maintenance includes scheduled servicing, wear-related work, an extended-warranty allowance and one replacement set of tires. Oil changes should not be added again. AAA assumes a five-year loan with 15% down and an experienced, accident-free insured driver under 65 living in a city or suburb. [1] [2]
Another accounting trap is adding the entire purchase price or loan principal payments on top of depreciation. Depreciation already represents the vehicle value consumed during ownership. Interest is an additional expense; counting principal too would double-count the purchase. A cash-flow budget and an ownership-cost calculation answer different questions. [3]
More miles, lower cost per mile
A lower cost per mile need not mean lower total spending. Driving farther spreads ownership expenses over more miles, even while annual costs rise. Federal Highway Administration estimates put average travel at 10,787 miles per registered light-duty vehicle in 2024. That includes cars, SUVs, vans and pickups of all ages—not specifically new vehicles. [1] [4]
A simple interpolation between AAA’s 10,000- and 15,000-mile annual-cost estimates gives approximately $1.05 per mile at that national mileage. This is a calculation from published figures, not a separate AAA finding. It retains AAA’s vehicle mix and five-year assumptions, explaining why roughly $1 is a more useful starting point than 86 cents near average per-vehicle mileage. [1] [4]
Which “average car”?
AAA’s sample covers 34 top-selling models across seven categories, including selected hybrids and electric vehicles, with a sales-weighted average sticker price of $39,376. Kelley Blue Book’s October 2026 market-wide average transaction price was $51,109 before consumer incentives. These are different measures and vehicle mixes. AAA’s estimate does not establish ownership costs for a $51,000 car; scaling every expense by the price difference would be misleading. [5] [6]
Location matters too. Idling, short trips and stop-and-go driving can reduce gasoline fuel economy, but the evidence does not justify one universal city surcharge. A hypothetical $150 monthly parking bill adds 18 cents per mile at 10,000 annual miles—not a national parking average. Add applicable tolls and other expenses without duplicating existing allowances. [3] [5] [7]
Five years is not a lifetime
AAA’s estimate does not cover every repair through scrappage. A 2021 Argonne-led report’s review of historical data finds that maintenance and repair spending per mile rises with vehicle age, while identifying substantial disagreement and sampling limitations among repair datasets. Its older price assumptions cannot supply a current lifetime dollar estimate. Roughly $1 per mile plus parking and tolls is therefore a starting budget—not a promise about a particular car’s lifetime cost. [1] [2] [3]
Sources
- [1] Download PDF
- [2] Download PDF
- [3] Comprehensive Total Cost of Ownership Quantification for Vehicles with Different Size Classes and Powertrains
- [4] Table VM-1 - Policy | Federal Highway Administration
- [5] AAA: New Vehicle Ownership Costs Hit $12,863 Annually
- [6] October 2026 Kelley Blue Book Average Transaction Price tables
- [7] Many Factors Affect MPG